SCCOTUS Act (H.R. 8992)

Summary

Creates a panel of 13 randomly selected circuit judges to review all petitions and decide which cases the Supreme Court will hear each term.

What problem does this solve?

The current process for selecting Supreme Court cases lacks openness and gives nine Justices sole power to decide which legal issues are heard. This bill creates a rotating panel of 13 circuit judges to review petitions and grant cases based on clear criteria, adding oversight to the process.

What does this bill do?

Establishes a Supreme Court Certification Panel

Creates a new 13-member panel of circuit court judges responsible for reviewing all petitions for writs of certiorari filed with the Supreme Court.

Creates a rotating panel of circuit judges

The panel will consist of 13 circuit judges, one from each U.S. court of appeals, selected randomly for a single term. No judge can serve consecutive terms.

Sets new rules for granting Supreme Court cases

Requires the agreement of at least 4 of the 13 panel members to grant a petition. Each grant must include a written statement explaining the reason.

Defines criteria for accepting cases

Specifies that cases can only be accepted for compelling reasons, such as conflicts between lower courts or important, unsettled questions of federal law.

Requires public reporting on case selection

Mandates that the panel issue a public report at the end of each term summarizing the number of petitions reviewed, granted, and denied, along with statistical data.

Sets ethics and disqualification rules

Panel judges are subject to the Code of Conduct for U.S. Judges and must be disqualified from a case if they previously participated in it in a lower court.

Who does this affect?

Federal judges
People petitioning the Supreme Court
Lawyers

What is the real world impact?

•

Increases transparency in case selection

Creates a public process for choosing which cases the Supreme Court hears. The panel must provide written reasons for granting a case and publish annual statistics on its decisions.

•

Reduces the Supreme Court's power

Transfers the authority to decide which cases to hear from the nine Supreme Court Justices to a rotating panel of 13 lower court judges. This significantly limits the Court's control over its own docket.

•

Could be used to influence the Court's agenda

Could be a way to limit the power of a Supreme Court with a specific political leaning. By spreading the decision-making among a larger, rotating group of judges, it may change the types of cases that reach the Court.

When does this start?

The rules for the new panel must be created within one year of the bill becoming law.

Rule Creation Deadline

The Judicial Conference of the United States must create rules for how the panel will work no later than one year after this bill becomes law.